SEED Materials

Technical guide / Concrete production

Slump and strength: two tests, two different questions

Understand what a fresh-concrete consistency test tells you, why it cannot replace a strength result, and how to record adjustments.

The idea, illustrated

Consistency now. Resistance at the stated age.

Slump

Fresh consistency under a defined test method.

Compressive strength

Failure load ÷ loaded area, with method, age and curing recorded.

Concept drawings, not test instructions or apparatus dimensions. A slump result is not a strength prediction.

Define what each test measures

A slump test observes the change in shape of a fresh-concrete sample under a standardised procedure. It provides information about consistency within the scope of the method. Compressive strength testing measures the load resistance of a prepared and cured specimen at a stated age.

ASTM C143/C143M's public significance statement warns that the relationship between slump and strength is not clear and consistent under field conditions. Use the edition and procedure adopted by the project for testing. [source]

A low-slump result is not proof of high strength. A mixture with a water-reducing admixture can behave differently from one made workable by extra water. A visual impression of “wet” or “stiff” does not establish the water–cementitious ratio or the eventual strength.

Make the fresh test comparable

Record sample identity, batch or truck reference, location, sampling time and relevant elapsed times. Use the specified sampling and test procedure, suitable equipment and trained personnel. Record the result in the units required by the project.

Keep the target range and the measured value separate. A test outside the specified range needs the agreed response, not a change to the target after seeing the result. Repeat tests, rejected samples and adjustments should remain visible in the record.

Different concrete types may require different test methods. A conventional slump test should not be assumed to characterise every very stiff, highly flowable or self-compacting mixture. Confirm the method's scope before selecting the form on the test sheet.

Control any adjustment at the point of delivery

Water addition is a controlled decision. NRMCA's jobsite guidance describes adjustments within the authorised mixture and specification, with proper recording and mixing. It does not support unlimited addition until the concrete looks easy to place. [source]

Before an adjustment, identify the mix, the quantity remaining, previous additions, the permitted water limit and who may authorise the change. Follow the agreed mixing and retesting procedure. An admixture adjustment likewise needs an approved product, dosage and procedure; it is not a universal remedy.

The delivery record should allow the final batch condition to be reconstructed. If the limit or previous additions cannot be established, resolve the discrepancy through the project's acceptance process.

Read a strength report with its specimen details

Compressive stress is calculated from failure load divided by loaded area. For a deliberately simple arithmetic example, a 150 mm cube with loaded area 150 × 150 = 22,500 mm² and failure load 675,000 N gives 30 N/mm², or 30 MPa.

Compressive stress = failure load ÷ loaded area

This example demonstrates units only. It is not a recommended specimen, test instruction or acceptance decision. The actual laboratory uses the dimensions, preparation, loading and reporting rules of the adopted method.

Identify whether the report concerns cubes or cylinders, the age, curing condition and test method. Do not compare cube and cylinder numbers as if they were interchangeable or apply an unsupported universal conversion factor. NRMCA CIP 35 explains the role of compressive-strength specimens and why their testing conditions matter. [source]

Use each result for the right decision

The fresh-concrete record supports a decision about the delivered condition under the project's requirements. Later strength results support the decisions defined by the acceptance specification. Neither record should be detached from the batch and placement it represents.

A satisfactory slump does not release a structural member for loading or formwork removal. Conversely, one later strength value does not prove that fresh placement, compaction, curing and all durability requirements were satisfactory.

  • For a fresh result outside limits: record, notify and apply the agreed response.
  • For a strength result requiring investigation: verify sample identity, testing and the applicable acceptance criteria.
  • For an in-place construction decision: use the designer's specified evidence and authorisation.

The testing and traceability guide shows how these separate records connect.

Sources & scope

Primary references consulted for this guide. Worked examples are illustrative. Apply the project specification and the appropriate adopted test methods.

  1. ASTM C143/C143M-26b · Public significance and use

    Public significance and use, section 5.1 Note 2; the full paid standard has not been reproduced.

  2. NRMCA CIP 26 · Jobsite addition of water

    Controlled adjustments within the authorised mixture and specification.

  3. NRMCA CIP 35 · Testing compressive strength

    Strength measurement and the purpose of specimens.